Guides · 5 minute read

Selling a faulty console: what counts, what to tell us, what happens

A faulty console is still worth selling. We use two grades for consoles, Working and Faulty, and Faulty has its own price on every model we buy, shown on the sell page before you order. This guide covers what counts as faulty, what to tell us, and what happens when it arrives. First, though, the question that decides everything else: is it a console we buy?

What we buy. PlayStation 5, in its original, Slim and Pro models. Xbox Series X and Xbox Series S. Steam Deck, both the LCD and the OLED. ROG Ally and ROG Ally X. With a console we also buy official controllers, disc games and, for Xbox, Storage Expansion Cards, but never on their own. If yours is not on that list, a Nintendo Switch for example, we cannot buy it, faulty or working, and it is better to know that before you pack anything.

What counts as faulty. Working means it turns on, plays games and has no faults, with normal signs of use. Faulty is anything else. In the words of our terms, that includes a console that will not switch on, beeps or shows a light code, light liquid damage, a cracked case or a cracked or dead screen, and a console that has been opened or repaired before. It also covers a disc drive that will not read or eject, no picture or an HDMI fault, overheating or switching itself off, a console stuck updating, and a controller that will not connect. On a Steam Deck or ROG Ally it also covers a screen with lines or no picture, joystick drift or sticking buttons, and charging or battery trouble. All of those are Faulty, at the Faulty price.

The rule that matters more than whether it works: it must be complete. Parts can be faulty, but none can be missing. As the sell page puts it, it is still Faulty as long as nothing is missing inside, even if it won't switch on. For a PS5 or Xbox that means the motherboard, power supply, SSD, cooling fan and heatsink, wifi and Bluetooth module, power and eject buttons, USB ports, and all the panels and screws. For a Steam Deck or ROG Ally it means the screen, battery, SSD, fan, speakers, both sticks, all the face buttons, D-pad, triggers, bumpers and back buttons, the USB-C port, headphone jack, microSD slot, wifi and Bluetooth, the back panel and all its screws, plus both trackpads on a Steam Deck and the fingerprint power button on a ROG Ally. If a part was taken out for a repair that never happened, put it back before you post it.

One thing we cannot take at all: a Steam Deck or ROG Ally with a swollen battery. If the back bulges or the screen is lifting, please do not post it, because it is not safe in the post. Take it to a local recycling point instead. The sell page asks about it for every handheld.

What to tell us. When you choose Faulty, the sell page asks What's wrong, with a row of short answers to tap, such as Disc drive, Overheats or switches off, or Joystick drift or buttons, and a box for anything else, up to 300 characters. Both are optional and neither changes the price. They tell the person testing your console where to look first. Something like it crashes after an hour, or the left stick drifts up, is exactly the kind of note that helps. If there is a fault you know about, say so: Faulty is one price whatever the fault, so telling us costs you nothing.

Before you post it, sign out and reset it if you can. Our reset guides for the PS5, the Xbox and the two handhelds cover the official steps, including what to do from a computer or phone if a faulty console will not get as far as its menus. Send it well protected, without cables, stand or box, with any controllers or games you listed. Every console order gets a free Royal Mail Tracked 24 QR code to show at any Post Office, and your price is locked for 10 days from ordering.

What happens at the check. Your console is checked within one working day of arriving. If it matches your answers, you are paid the price you were quoted, by bank transfer, within 48 hours of it arriving, counted Monday to Friday. If it does not, for example parts are missing, it is bent or corroded, it is banned from playing online, or you chose Working and it turns out to have a fault, we send a revised offer with the reason. You can accept it, and we pay within 48 hours of you accepting, Monday to Friday, or you can say no and we post the whole parcel back to you free, console and extras together.

Faulty controllers count too. An official DualSense or Xbox Wireless Controller is bought faulty as well as working, so a pad with drift is worth adding to the order rather than throwing away. To see what yours is worth, open the sell page for your console, choose your model and edition, pick Faulty, and the price appears straight away.

Minty, the ReMint mascot
While you are hereCheck what yours is worth
Get my price

Every console we buy · PS5 · Xbox Series X and S · Steam Deck and ROG Ally

Keep reading